Public sector unions have begun balloting their members on a sub-inflation deal that Kevin Callinan, lead negotiator for the ICTU Public Services Committee, deemed good enough to call off the 12 November strike. He did so in the dead of night, about 20 hours before the strike was set to begin.
Explaining the decision by the TUI Executive Committee to recommend accepting the deal, union president Anthony Quinn said “it was the best that could be achieved by the union representatives in the current circumstances.” What absolute nonsense!
12 November was an historic opportunity to fight back against decades of attacks on public sector workers. Despite Jack Chambers’s comical assertion that the last-minute deal was more “coincidental than connected” to the threat of strike action during the European Political Community (EPC) summit, it’s clear the ruling class was shaking in their boots.
With militant action we could have won everything we wanted to, including compensation for cuts to real pay since Covid and a sliding scale that links future wages to inflation. Instead, the trade union bureaucracy once again threw a lifeline to the government, betraying the overwhelming strike mandate the rank-and-file had given them.
But hey, at least the gaggle of war criminals and charlatans who descended on Dublin for Thursday’s summit, followed by a glamorous dinner in the National Gallery, did not have their affairs disrupted by 300,000 striking workers.
A cursory glance at the comments beneath the unions’ social media posts gives a sense of the mood of anger among public sector workers:
“I’ll be voting no. Then giving up my membership. It’s clear that forsa were working on behalf of the government with this ‘deal’”
“A union bargaining for its members to take a pay cut isn’t fit for purpose”
“This is a joke. A mockery of the Irish and a waste of everyone’s time… if you’re gonna fight, fight. Not back down for a useless deal”
This is only a small sample. We could go on.
Pay deal vs inflation
So what exactly did union tops negotiate in return for squandering this once-in-a-generation opportunity? The proposed agreement offers a pay increase of 10.75 percent from September 2026 to March 2029. In truth, the real figure is 9.75 with the extra 1 percent coming from a ‘local bargaining’ clause not everyone will benefit from. But, for the sake of argument, let’s take the 10.75 percent at face value.
This amounts to an average pay increase of 3.9 percent per year. Meanwhile, annual inflation as of October was 4.3 percent, up from 4.1 percent in September.
Workers on the lowest end of the pay scale will be eligible for total increases of up to 17.3 percent over the 33 months covered by the deal. But in reality, these are the workers most affected by price inflation on essentials like housing, energy and travel, which has been much higher than the headline rate – as much as 10.7 percent per year. So no matter how you slice it, public sector pay will not be protected from inflation.
Then there are the losses in real pay of at least 5 percent that public sector workers have already suffered over the past five years – all because of previous rotten deals accepted by the union leadership without a fight.
And to be sure, the attacks on real pay are only the beginning.
Of the 28 page document outlining the agreement, the majority is dedicated to the ‘productivity reforms’ the government intends to make to the public sector – involving the use of AI and so on – with the kind permission of the union tops. In plain English this means: cuts, austerity, a further deterioration of working conditions, and further worsening of the public services being provided to the rest of us.
That’s the reality of the ‘deal’ being offered to workers. But even that’s not all. The agreement also contains a review clause in case economic conditions change. Jack Chambers has already said that the government will use this to renege on even the meagre, sub-inflation pay raises being offered once the economy slows down.
Nobody will be surprised by the callousness and cynicism of Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael. But the question is, why are the trade union tops going along with it when they had a clear mandate to fight for more?
Callinan’s argument in favour of the deal hinges on projections that say inflation will plummet in 2027 following a miraculous recovery for global oil supplies. Very good. Only that this time last year inflation was projected at 1.9 percent for 2026. So much for ‘projections’.
This is exactly why public sector workers need a deal that directly links future pay to inflation, as Callinan himself said back in June – before the union leadership reneged on all their promises to put up a proper fight.
In reality, Callinan and co. were never interested in fighting for a decent deal for their members – the workers, incidentally, whose dues pay for the six-figure salaries of these top union bureaucrats. They only cared about getting a deal over the line that they could present to the rank-and-file without being laughed out of the room. Once they believed they had done so, they immediately folded instead of fighting for more.
As we explained previously, the union tops were afraid of a mobilisation of the working class that could break outside of their control just as much as the government was.
‘Social Partnership’ or class struggle?
One of the main arguments repeated ad nauseam by the Irish union leadership – in unison with the government and the capitalist press – is that negotiations and so-called ‘social partnership’ are the way for workers to get their ‘fair share’. Perhaps strikes are common in the rest of the world – we are told – but here in Ireland things are different: we sit down at the table, and through some ‘difficult negotiations’ we obtain a deal that is fair for everyone – bosses, government and workers alike.
Indeed, the deal on the table refers explicitly to this when it says: “The parties to the Agreement confirm their view that effective social dialogue […] is more important than ever in these times of geopolitical uncertainty.” This and not workplace militancy, we are told in the deal, is how we will find “the way forward” between “Government, Employer and Trade Union representatives”.
Is that so? Is cross-class “social dialogue” really in the interests of workers today?
So-called ‘Social Partnership’ has a long history in Ireland, but it became formalised in the late 1980s on the corpse of the militant struggles of the 1960s and ‘70s. These culminated in the 1979-80 movement for PAYE reform, where 700,000 workers took part in a general strike despite initial fierce pushback from the ICTU leadership.
The union bureaucrats were terrified at the prospect of getting sidelined entirely in the face of growing rank-and-file militancy. The bosses and the government, meanwhile, understood they could not launch a frontal attack on the working class without triggering another mass movement. All having something to gain therefore, the government, bosses and union leaders hatched a plan to cut across the wave of militancy. The unions would accept a series of cuts in return for some breadcrumbs sprinkled on top.
In reality, any concessions obtained during the ensuing period of ‘social partnership’ were only a thin cloak hiding the massive transfer of wealth from the working class to the capitalists that took place in the so-called ‘Celtic Tiger’ years. The share of wages in the national economy fell from 71.2 percent in 1981-1990 to just 54 percent in 2001-2007.
Then came the 2008 crash. When the economy was growing, the government and the bosses could handily afford small pay increases to help the union bureaucracy keep their members in line. But when Ireland was plunged into recession, the ruling class launched a savage, brazen offensive against the working class.
In 2009, the government announced that instead of implementing pay increases it agreed to only a few months prior, it would cut public sector pay and workforce numbers. So when Jack Chambers today says that the government will back out of this new agreement once growth slows down, we can take him at his word. We’ve been here before.
Back then, the union leadership – under pressure from its members – called an all-out public sector strike at the end of 2009. But instead of escalating the struggle, they cancelled a threatened follow-up strike (déjà vu?) in return for negotiations where unions would get a say in how to implement €1 billion in cuts. The final result of those negotiations was the Croke Park Agreement in 2010, which imposed brutal cuts on public sector workers. In effect, social partnership between the government and the public sector unions was then restored.
A number of agreements followed after Croke Park, which bought the government a relative degree of industrial peace, while continuing to leave public sector workers worse off in real terms.
The lesson is clear. Whenever workers in Ireland have won concessions, it was never through clever negotiating. It has always been through militant struggle on the streets and in the workplaces. And time and again, these gains have subsequently been undermined or surrendered by the union tops at the first opportunity.
Vote to reject the sell-out deal!
It is difficult to say in advance how the balloting on the deal will go.
If a majority of public sector workers vote to reject the agreement against the recommendation of their leadership, that will send shockwaves through the labour movement in Ireland. Such a result would signify a monumental vote of no confidence in the rotten tactics of the current trade union leadership. With the sense of betrayal numerous union members are rightfully feeling right now, this isn’t out of the question.
That said, many will vote in favour of the deal not because they think it’s ‘fair’, but out of exhaustion and demoralisation. The thinking will be: ‘What’s the point of continuing to fight if we are being led by generals who don’t want us to win?’
But there’s another side to this. The fact is that currently the Irish government is enjoying record tax surpluses and could afford to throw money at the public sector to avoid strike action during the EPC summit. Despite leaving pay below inflation, the deal will cost the government at least €5.2 billion.
But once these surpluses disappear – as they inevitably will because they are predicated on a small handful of tech and pharma multinationals – then cuts to pay will again be on the order of the day like in 2008. That is, not only in real but in absolute terms.
In fact, the ruling class can see the writing on the walls. It emerged recently that Apple is now saving more money by using Singapore as a tax haven than Ireland. Moreover, the turbulence around tech stocks in the past weeks demonstrates that a crash isn’t far off.
The government is under pressure to reduce the growth rate of public spending now. Otherwise, the cuts they have to make down the line will be even greater, and so will the fightback by the working class. One way or another, a showdown with the workers is being prepared in the coming period.
But even once economic growth and corporate tax intake slow down, the money exists to permanently link pay to inflation and to make up for all the losses in real pay already suffered by workers. After all, the purchasing power that workers lose as a result of inflation doesn’t disappear into thin air. It’s only transferred into the pockets of the bosses.
That money lies not only in the hands of the multinationals, but also in the banks – AIB, Bank of Ireland and PTSB – that only remain in business today because the Irish working class was forced to pay €64 billion through brutal austerity to rescue them after 2008.
Of course, we don’t expect Fianna Fáil or Fine Gael to nationalise the banks to use their wealth to meet the needs of workers. But a militant labour movement with a fighting leadership could not only win a proper pay deal now, but also prepare workers for the revolutionary struggles ahead which will sooner or later pose the question concretely of who should control these vast resources – the bankers or the workers who paid with sweat and blood to bail them out.




